Good on Paper follows Andrea Singer, a struggling stand-up comedian who has spent years putting her career ahead of romance. After a chance encounter on a flight, she meets Dennis, a seemingly perfect Yale-educated hedge fund manager who appears to check every single box on her list. However, as their relationship develops, Andrea's comedian instincts kick in as she notices bizarre inconsistencies in Dennis's stories. Teaming up with her sharp-witted best friend, she launches an amateur investigation into her seemingly too-good-to-be-true boyfriend, uncovering a web of absurd lies.
Written by and starring comedian Iliza Shlesinger, the film was inspired by her own real-life bizarre experiences with dating a compulsive liar in Los Angeles. Director Kimmy Gatewood brought the semi-autobiographical script to screen, aiming to blend sharp stand-up observational humor with a twisty romantic thriller dynamic. The production focused on authentic comedy club settings and relatable dating anxieties.
Critics offered mixed reviews, praising Iliza Shlesinger's comedic energy and the film's bold premise based on real-life deception, while noting that the tonal shifts between romantic comedy and thriller felt uneven. Reviewers commended Ryan Hansen for playing against type as the delightfully unhinged liar. The humorous dialogue received favorable marks.
Audiences enjoyed the movie as a fun, breezy comedy that offered a cathartic look at modern dating disasters and manipulative relationships. Viewers who related to dating red flags found it highly entertaining.
The film earned recognition across streaming platforms for its comedic performances and entertaining exploration of modern dating red flags.
Iliza Shlesinger drew inspiration directly from her personal stand-up material and real-life dating experiences, turning personal frustration into sharp cinematic comedy.
Balancing comedic improvisation with tight mystery plotting required careful rehearsal schedules between the lead actors to ensure the psychological gaslighting landed effectively.
During the filming of the restaurant confrontation scene, Shlesinger improvised several biting insults that caught co-star Ryan Hansen completely off guard, resulting in authentic laughter.
Casting discussions focused on finding a male actor who could balance charming trustworthiness with underlying absurdity for the deceptive boyfriend role.
The film explores modern dating culture, compulsive lying, female intuition, friendship, self-worth, and the red flags we choose to ignore for love.
The climax concludes with Andrea publicly exposing Dennis's elaborate web of lies at a comedy show, reclaiming her agency and walking away with her best friend.
The title refers to someone who looks flawless on paper—checking every superficial box—yet turns out to be a total disaster in reality.
The original soundtrack features upbeat pop tracks and snappy comedic cues that complement the fast-paced Los Angeles dating scene.
Similar films include Promising Young Woman, The To Do List, Ibiza, and Someone Great.