Mollie is a fiercely independent Manhattan accountant who becomes pregnant by a married, sleazy client who promptly abandons her. While navigating single motherhood, she embarks on an obsessive search for the perfect father figure for her unborn child, running through a string of disastrous suitors. Along the way, she crosses paths with James Ubriacco, a charming, laid-back taxi driver who drives her to the hospital during labor and becomes a devoted friend and father figure. The film's unique twist is that the entire chaotic dating world is narrated through the cynical, wisecracking inner thoughts of Mikey, the newborn baby observing them from inside.