In 1920s Harlem, Irene Redfield, a Black woman living a comfortable life, unexpectedly meets her childhood friend Clare Kendry. Clare has been passing as white and is married to a wealthy man who is unaware of her heritage. Irene is both fascinated and unsettled by Clare's choices and her growing presence in her life. As the two women become entangled, tension, jealousy and secrets threaten to unravel everything.