When Senator Ransom Stoddard and his wife Hallie return to the small Western town of Shinbone for the funeral of a seemingly forgotten rancher named Tom Doniphon, a local newspaper editor asks why such a distinguished man would attend. Stoddard answers by telling the story of his arrival years earlier as an idealistic young lawyer. He found a town terrorised by the outlaw Liberty Valance, and he dared to confront him with the law instead of a gun. The tale that follows reveals the truth behind the legend that made his career.