After receiving a mysterious antique ventriloquist dummy named Billy on their doorstep, a young married couple experiences a horrific tragedy. When his wife is brutally murdered, grieving widower Jamie Ashen returns to his eerie hometown of Raven's Fair to investigate. He uncovers a dark local legend surrounding Mary Shaw, a vengeful ventriloquist executed decades earlier. As mysterious deaths plague the town, Jamie must uncover the terrifying truth behind the nursery rhyme that links them all.