Ally Darling reads a magazine article claiming that women who have slept with more than twenty men have almost no chance of finding a husband. Having reached exactly twenty, she panics and decides to track down her exes in the hope that one of them is the one she let slip away. Her charming but irresponsible neighbor Colin offers to help her with the search in exchange for a place to hide from his own romantic entanglements. As the quest goes on, Ally begins to wonder whether the right man has been next door all along.
What's Your Number? is loosely based on the 2007 novel 20 Times a Lady by Karyn Bosnak, a comedic story about a woman who wants to avoid exceeding a magic number of past partners. The screenplay was written by Gabrielle Allan and Jennifer Crittenden, and Mark Mylod, who had directed episodes of television comedies, took charge of the film. Anna Faris, already known for her comic talents in the Scary Movie films, took the lead role of Ally. Chris Evans, shortly before becoming Captain America, was cast as Colin. The supporting cast included Ari Graynor, Blythe Danner, Ed Begley Jr., Andy Samberg and Chris Pratt. The film was released in September 2011 by 20th Century Fox. It was positioned as a romantic comedy in the vein of the successful female-driven comedies of the time.
Critics were largely negative, calling the film predictable and uneven. Many said that the premise made the heroine look foolish and that the humor was crude. Still, several reviewers singled out Anna Faris's energy and her chemistry with Chris Evans as the best part of the film.
The film did not perform well at the box office, earning only about 30 million dollars worldwide. Audiences did not turn out in large numbers during its release window. Over time, it has found a small following on television and streaming. Fans of the two leads often remember it fondly.
What's Your Number? did not receive notable awards. It was nominated for a handful of popular and comedy awards but did not win any. It is generally remembered as a modest, lighthearted entry in the genre.
Mylod wanted to make a romantic comedy that played with the idea that society judges women by their past, while keeping the tone breezy. He leaned on the physical comedy skills of Anna Faris. The film's look is bright and colorful, in line with the genre.
The film was shot in Boston and its surroundings, which meant dealing with changing weather and busy locations. The cast included many well-known supporting actors, so scheduling was a challenge. The comedy scenes also required many takes to capture improvisation.
The film is a romantic comedy about self-worth and the pressure that women feel to fit a certain image. It plays with the question of whether a person's past defines their future. Friendship and family are important, especially the relationship between Ally and her sisters. The story also looks at fear of commitment, as both Ally and Colin avoid real intimacy. Its central message is about accepting oneself and recognizing true love. The tone remains light and often silly.
After meeting many of her exes, Ally realizes that none of them is the right person and that she has been chasing the wrong question. She understands that the number itself does not matter and that what counts is how she feels about the person in front of her. Colin, who has been supporting her all along, declares his love, and Ally accepts. The film ends with the two of them together, happy and unconcerned about numbers. It is a classic romantic comedy resolution.
The number in the title refers to the total count of people a person has slept with, which is the film's main comic hook. The question mark turns it into a nosy and slightly embarrassing question. The title therefore sets up the premise in a single sentence. In French, the film was released as Sex List, which highlights the idea of a list of past partners.