Kassie Larson is a smart, independent Manhattan woman who decides it is time to have a baby using artificial insemination despite being single. During a raucous insemination party thrown by her neurotic best friend Wally, a drunken Wally accidentally swaps the donor sample with his own. Seven years later, Kassie returns to New York with her precocious, eccentric young son Sebastian, who shares uncanny behavioral traits with Wally. When Wally slowly pieces together the truth, he must navigate fatherhood, secret identity, and his lingering romantic feelings for Kassie.
Based on Jeffrey Eugenides's acclaimed 2004 short story "Baster," the film adaptation was developed by indie directors Josh Gordon and Will Speck. The filmmakers wanted to balance romantic comedy conventions with a quirky, character-driven premise focusing on unconventional fatherhood. Screenwriter Allan Loeb adapted the literary material to highlight the comedic and neurotic chemistry between Jennifer Aniston and Jason Bateman. The production captured the vibrant, urban atmosphere of New York City.
Critical reception for the film was generally mixed, with reviewers praising the effortless chemistry between Jennifer Aniston and Jason Bateman and the charming child performance. However, some critics felt the plot was overly predictable and relied on safe romantic comedy formulas. Audiences responded moderately at the box office, making it a decent financial performer that found a loyal following on home video. It is remembered as a sweet, comforting romantic comedy.
Jason Bateman and Jennifer Aniston were close friends off-screen, which translated into instant comedic rapport and natural dialogue delivery during their apartment scenes. Child actor Thomas Robinson was praised by the cast and crew for his professional focus and endearing portrayal of Sebastian. The production utilized real Manhattan neighborhoods to capture authentic New York City backdrops. Directors encouraged the lead actors to improvise subtle comedic beats during emotional dialogue exchanges.
The film explores unconventional fatherhood, modern family structures, and the unspoken love of a lifelong platonic best friend. It highlights personal growth, responsibility, and the realization of what truly makes a parent. Neurotic anxiety and platonic boundaries turning into romance drive the emotional narrative. It also touches upon single motherhood and child-rearing.
Wally confesses the accidental sperm swap truth to Kassie, leading to an emotional confrontation and temporary heartbreak. However, Kassie soon realizes how deeply Wally loves Sebastian and how wonderful a father he has secretly been all along. She forgives him, and the three of them embrace as a newly formed, loving family. The conclusion delivers a heartwarming, romantic resolution to the mistaken identity secret.
The title refers directly to the accidental physical switch of the donor sample cup by drunken Wally at the start of the movie. It highlights the core catalyst that sets off the entire comedic premise. The name signals a lighthearted romantic comedy involving secret parentage.
Jon Brion composed a whimsical, acoustic-driven orchestral score that accentuated the romantic comedy tone.
Friends with Kids, The Back-Up Plan, Life as We Know It, What Happens in Vegas