Eddie Cantrow is a perpetually single, amiable sports store owner in his forties who feels pressured by society and his family to finally settle down. He impulsively marries a seemingly wonderful woman named Lila after a whirlwind romance, believing he has finally found his soulmate. However, during their honeymoon in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, Eddie discovers to his utter horror that his new bride has deeply irritating habits, obnoxious traits, and a completely different personality. To make matters worse, he soon meets and falls head over heels for a down-to-earth, kind-hearted woman named Miranda while vacationing at the resort. Trapped in a disastrous marriage while desperately pursuing a new romance, Eddie embarks on a hilarious spiral of poor decisions.
The film is a remake of Elaine May's acclaimed 1972 dark comedy of the same name, which was originally scripted by Neil Simon and starred Charles Grodin. Directors Peter and Bobby Farrelly sought to update the classic premise for the 2000s, injecting their trademark brand of outrageous, boundary-pushing physical comedy while maintaining the central romantic dilemma. The inspiration came from exploring the anxiety of commitment and the disastrous consequences of rushing into holy matrimony based on superficial attraction.
Professional critics offered mixed reviews, with some praising the film's fearless comedic audacity, energetic pacing, and the charming performances of Ben Stiller and Malin Akerman. Other reviewers felt that the humor relied too heavily on gross-out gags and mean-spirited situations that strayed too far from the subtle satire of the 1972 original. Audiences generally enjoyed the lighthearted entertainment, appreciating the chemistry between the lead actors and the absurd vacation mishaps. Viewers found the honeymoon disaster scenarios highly amusing, making it a solid comedy choice for home viewing. The film achieved moderate box office success worldwide, carving out a niche among fans of modern American slapstick comedy. It received minor recognition within comedy film nomination circles for its supporting performances and outrageous comedic set pieces.
Directors Peter and Bobby Farrelly drew inspiration from classic romantic farces and traditional slapstick comedies, blending awkward social situations with eccentric character traits. Production took place across scenic beach resorts in Mexico, requiring the cast to brave intense sun and water conditions during elaborate comedic sequences. A notoriously painful sunburn sequence required Ben Stiller to endure hours of elaborate prosthetic makeup applications and physical discomfort on set. Before Ben Stiller secured the lead role of Eddie Cantrow, several prominent comedy actors of the era were considered during early script development.
The story humorously explores the perils of impulsive decision-making and the societal pressures that push people into marriage before they are truly ready. It examines the stark difference between surface-level physical infatuation and deep, compatible emotional connection. Themes of regret, commitment phobia, and moral hypocrisy run throughout Eddie's desperate attempts to rectify his marital mistake. Additionally, it pokes fun at vacation culture, resort romances, and the unexpected ways people discover who they truly are.
There's Something About Mary, Meet the Parents, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, The 40-Year-Old Virgin