A cynical screenwriter suffering from acute writer's block has been scarred by childhood trauma and abandoned by love, leading him to believe that true romance does not exist. Commissioned by his cynical Hollywood agent to write a predictable romantic comedy script despite his utter disdain for the genre, his life takes an unexpected turn at a charity dinner. There, he meets a stunning, quick-witted woman named Jordan who is already engaged to a dull commodities broker. Undeterred by her relationship status, the narrator embarks on an elaborate platonic friendship, exploring every quirky archetype of falling in love while desperately trying to win her heart.
Directed by Justin Reardon, the romantic comedy script by Chris Shafer and Paul Vicknair circulated in Hollywood development circles for years before securing financing. The production aimed to craft a meta-romantic comedy that poked fun at conventional genre tropes while telling a heartfelt emotional story about overcoming commitment phobia.
Summary of professional reviews: Professional critics gave the film mixed-to-negative reviews, criticizing its overly quirky meta-humor and disjointed narrative pacing while praising Chris Evans and Michelle Monaghan's undeniable chemistry.
Public reception: The film found a modest niche audience among romantic comedy enthusiasts and fans of its star-studded ensemble cast on home video platforms.
Awards obtained: While not a major awards contender, the film garnered appreciation for its playful self-aware screenplay.
Director inspirations: Justin Reardon drew inspiration from classic screwball comedies and French New Wave meta-narratives to structure the screenwriter's imaginative fantasies.
Production difficulties: Balancing the rapid-fire fantasy sequences and surreal dream vignettes within a modest independent production schedule required precise editing choices.
Anecdote on a particular scene: Chris Evans stepped into the romantic comedy genre as a palate cleanser between Marvel superhero blockbusters, embracing the quirky comedic tone.
Initially planned casting: Chris Evans and Michelle Monaghan anchored the lead roles, supported by a quirky ensemble featuring Aubrey Plaza, Anthony Mackie, and Ioan Gruffudd.
The film explores commitment phobia, overcoming emotional trauma, the nature of romantic clichés, and learning to embrace vulnerability in relationships.
After realizing his fear of intimacy was pushing Jordan away, the screenwriter pours his genuine feelings into a rewritten script, winning Jordan back just as she calls off her engagement.
'Playing It Cool' refers to the protagonist's emotional defense mechanism of feigning indifference to avoid experiencing heartbreak.
Composed by Jake Monaco, the whimsical indie-pop score complements the protagonist's eccentric screenwriting fantasies and romantic daydreams.
500 Days of Summer, About Time, Crazy, Stupid, Love, Silver Linings Playbook, Not Another Teen Movie