Cleveland Heep is a weary, stuttering superintendent of a Philadelphia apartment complex who is haunted by a tragic past involving the murder of his family. One night, while investigating a disturbance by the building's pool, he rescues a mysterious young woman named Story from the water, only to discover she is actually a magical water nymph known as a "narf" from a bedtime fable who is being hunted by terrifying grass-like creatures. As Cleveland and the eccentric apartment tenants learn that they each play a crucial role in a mythical prophecy to help Story return home, they unite to protect her. The whimsical fantasy fairy tale delivers atmospheric mystery and allegorical storytelling.
Writer and director M. Night Shyamalan conceived the original dark fairy tale after inventing it as a bedtime story for his own young daughters, choosing to direct it as a deeply personal cinematic fable. The inspiration stemmed from exploring modern communal isolation and ancient folklore transposed into a mundane American apartment complex. The production team invested heavily in atmospheric night lighting and practical water creature effects. The script was structured as a modern bedtime story brought to life.
Professional critics gave overwhelmingly negative reviews, panning the film for its self-indulgent narrative, heavy-handed allegories, sluggish pacing, and Shyamalan casting himself in a prominent role as a prophetic writer whose ideas change the world. Reviewers noted that despite gorgeous cinematography by Christopher Doyle and a strong lead performance by Paul Giamatti, the fable felt overly precious. Public reception was weak, and the film underperformed at the box office, marking a critical turning point in Shyamalan's career.
Director M. Night Shyamalan drew visual inspiration from children's fantasy literature, bedtime fables, and classic ghost story cinema. Production took place on location at a custom-built apartment complex set in Levittown, Pennsylvania, surrounded by soundstages. During the filming of mystical pool sequences, Bryce Dallas Howard spent hours filming underwater without scuba gear to capture authentic nymph movements. Shyamalan cast himself as a character named Vick Ran, whose written works dictate the fate of the world.
The film explores community, belief in magic, grief recovery, storytelling, destiny, and protecting the vulnerable.
The magical climax sees the apartment tenants uniting in their assigned symbolic roles—the healer, the guild, the guardian—allowing giant eagles to arrive and carry Story safely back to her world.
The title refers directly to the mysterious magical water nymph Story, whom the superintendent rescues from the apartment swimming pool.
James Newton Howard composed an extraordinary, soaring orchestral fantasy score featuring delicate piano themes and enchanting strings that captured the fairytale wonder.
The film remains a fascinating, deeply polarizing fairy-tale experiment in M. Night Shyamalan's directorial filmography.
Bridge to Terabithia, Pan's Labyrinth, The Village