Lisa, a professional softball player, has just been cut from the national team and feels lost. She is dating Matty, a charming but self-centered baseball pitcher, when she meets George, a decent businessman who is facing a serious legal problem. As the two men compete for her attention, Lisa must figure out what she really wants from life and love. Meanwhile, George has to deal with his difficult father, who may have gotten him into trouble.
How Do You Know was written, directed and produced by James L. Brooks, the filmmaker behind Terms of Endearment and As Good as It Gets. Brooks had long been interested in stories about how people make decisions in love and in the workplace, and he wanted to explore the confusion of adulthood. He cast Reese Witherspoon as Lisa, Paul Rudd as George, Owen Wilson as Matty and Jack Nicholson as George's father, Charles. The film reunited Brooks with Nicholson, who had starred in two of his earlier hits. The project was developed over several years, and it was released in December 2010 by Columbia Pictures. It was an expensive production, with a budget of about 120 million dollars.
Critics were largely disappointed, finding the film uneven and the script talky and aimless. Many praised the performances of Rudd and Witherspoon but felt that the story did not live up to Brooks's earlier work. Nicholson's role was seen as a bright spot in an otherwise muddled film.
The film was a commercial failure, earning only about 49 million dollars worldwide against a budget of around 120 million. Audiences did not turn out in large numbers, and the film was quickly forgotten. It has found a small audience on television and streaming. It remains a minor entry in the careers of its stars.
How Do You Know did not receive notable awards. It was nominated for a few smaller prizes and for some negative awards. Its significance is mostly that it was a high-profile disappointment for a celebrated director.
Brooks has often said that he is interested in the way people communicate and fail to communicate in romantic relationships. He wanted to show characters who are smart but unsure of themselves. The film is a character-driven romantic comedy rather than a plot-heavy story.
The film was shot over a long period, and Brooks was known for demanding many takes. The budget grew, partly because of the high salaries of its stars. The editing process was also lengthy, as the director searched for the right tone.
One of the film's most talked-about aspects is that it features what is, so far, Jack Nicholson's last film role. His scenes as a morally compromised father are among the most memorable. The film also includes a funny scene in which Matty tries to impress Lisa with his lavish lifestyle.
The film is about love, uncertainty and the difficulty of making life decisions. It asks how people know when they have found the right person. It explores the pressure of success and the fear of failure, especially for athletes whose careers can end suddenly. Family loyalty and ethics are tested in George's storyline. The film also deals with the way we communicate or avoid communicating our feelings. Its tone is gently comic and reflective.
George is cleared of the charges against him after his father takes responsibility for the wrongdoing. Lisa realizes that Matty is not the person she wants to be with. She finds that George, with his honesty and kindness, is the better match. The film ends with the two of them together, ready to start a new chapter. It is a hopeful romantic ending.
The title is a question that expresses the characters' uncertainty about love and life. It asks how you know when something is right, a thought that runs through the story. The question also invites the audience to think about their own relationships. It reflects Brooks's interest in the mysteries of human connection.