Lucy Moderatz is a lonely, romantic token collector working for the Chicago transit authority who secretly harbors a massive crush on a handsome commuter she calls Peter. On Christmas Day, she saves Peter life after he is mugged and pushed onto the train tracks into a coma. At the hospital, a humorous mix-up leads Peters eccentric working-class family to mistake shy Lucy for his secret fiancée. Unable to shatter their heartwarming holiday joy, Lucy plays along with the deception, only to fall deeply in love with Peters warm, down-to-earth brother Jack. When Peter suddenly wakes up with amnesia, Lucy must confess the truth before her romantic fairy tale collapses.