Jenna Hunterson is a talented, small-town waitress trapped in an abusive, suffocating marriage with her insecure husband in the American South. Her only solace is inventing whimsical, brilliantly delicious homemade pies inspired by her daily emotional turmoil, such as "I Hate My Husband Pie." When she unexpectedly discovers she is pregnant with her husband's child, she begins a passionate, secret affair with her new gynecologist. As she saves money to escape her marriage, baking becomes her ultimate recipe for independence.