Kassie Larson is a smart, independent Manhattan woman who decides it is time to have a baby using artificial insemination despite being single. During a raucous insemination party thrown by her neurotic best friend Wally, a drunken Wally accidentally swaps the donor sample with his own. Seven years later, Kassie returns to New York with her precocious, eccentric young son Sebastian, who shares uncanny behavioral traits with Wally. When Wally slowly pieces together the truth, he must navigate fatherhood, secret identity, and his lingering romantic feelings for Kassie.