Michael Harding returns home from military school to find his mother deeply in love with a charming, attentive man named David Harris, who has quickly moved into their suburban household. Initially, David seems like the ideal husband and father figure, helping around the house and integrating smoothly into the family. However, Michael and his girlfriend begin noticing strange inconsistencies in David's past, uncovering a terrifying trail of unsolved family murders across the country. As Michael investigates further, he realizes David is a deranged serial killer who eliminates families when they fall short of his impossible perfection. A tense, deadly game of survival ensues as Michael tries to expose the monster hiding behind a charming suburban smile.