The Replacement follows Daniel, a dedicated, honest young architect living in a coastal Spanish town who is chosen to design a grand, modern new town hall building. When the town's elderly, beloved local doctor unexpectedly passes away, Daniel is hired to take over his medical clinic temporarily, only to discover a series of dark, hidden secrets involving the town's seemingly idyllic expatriate community—many of whom are elderly German retirees hiding fugitive Nazi war criminals from World War II. As Daniel investigates further, his life is threatened.