Eddie Cantrow is a perpetually single, amiable sports store owner in his forties who feels pressured by society and his family to finally settle down. He impulsively marries a seemingly wonderful woman named Lila after a whirlwind romance, believing he has finally found his soulmate. However, during their honeymoon in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, Eddie discovers to his utter horror that his new bride has deeply irritating habits, obnoxious traits, and a completely different personality. To make matters worse, he soon meets and falls head over heels for a down-to-earth, kind-hearted woman named Miranda while vacationing at the resort. Trapped in a disastrous marriage while desperately pursuing a new romance, Eddie embarks on a hilarious spiral of poor decisions.