The Little family of New York decides to adopt a child and unexpectedly brings home Stuart, a kind and well-mannered mouse. Their son George is initially embarrassed by his new brother, and the family cat Snowbell is horrified by the idea of living with a mouse. As Stuart wins over his new family, a gang of alley cats and a pair of impostors plot to take him away. Little by little, he proves that size has nothing to do with courage.