Richard Haig is a romantic, poetry-loving Cambridge professor living in Los Angeles who has a history of passionate flings with his beautiful students. When his current young girlfriend Kate announces she is pregnant, Richard agrees to marry her and settle down, only to realize he is actually falling deeply in love with her sharp-witted, cynical older sister Olivia. Juggling impending fatherhood, academic pressures, and family complications, Richard must figure out what truly matters in life. This quirky romantic comedy explores mid-life crises and unexpected romance.