Shining Girls follows Kirby Mazrachi, a quiet, traumatized Chicago newspaper archivist whose reality shifts unpredictably following a brutal, unsolved attempted murder years earlier. When a fresh Chicago murder case exhibits identical supernatural and forensic signatures to her own attack, Kirby teams up with veteran crime reporter Dan Velazquez to track down the elusive killer. They soon discover a terrifying truth: their attacker is a time-traveling serial killer named Harper Curtis who hunts 'shining girls'—bright, talented women across different decades—using a mysterious portal house in Chicago.