Set inside an exclusive, affluent Upper West Side apartment building in New York City called the Arconia, three eccentric strangers who share an obsessive passion for true-crime podcasts—a washed-up television actor named Charles, an eccentric Broadway director named Oliver, and a mysterious young interior designer named Mabel—find their lives upended when a gruesome real-life murder occurs in their building. Rather than waiting for police investigations, the unlikely trio forms an amateur true-crime podcasting team to solve the homicide while recording their audio investigation episode by episode. As hidden building secrets, eccentric neighbors, and dangerous suspects come to light, the podcasters navigate mounting personal peril. The comedic mystery series delivers sharp wit and brilliant New York atmosphere.