The Quarry follows a mysterious, silent vagrant preacher who arrives in a bleak, godforsaken small town in rural Texas and takes a job as the sexton at a local isolated church. Unbeknownst to the pious parishioners, the preacher is actually a ruthless criminal who murdered the town's former traveling clergyman and assumed his identity to hide from his past. As a suspicious local police chief begins piecing together the clues surrounding the missing clergyman, the false preacher's dark secrets threaten to erupt into violent retribution.