Menocchio follows Menocchio, a stubborn, elderly miller living in a remote alpine village in 16th-century northern Italy who is arrested and put on trial by the Roman Catholic Inquisition for heresy. Refusing to renounce his unorthodox theological beliefs—arguing that God is present in all matter, that all religions are equal, and that the universe emerged from chaos like cheese forming from milk—Menocchio defends his peasant philosophy against ruthless cardinal inquisitors. As torture and pressure mount, he remains steadfast in his spiritual freedom.