Jesse Fisher is a thirty-five-year-old university admissions officer living in New York who feels nostalgic, unfulfilled, and alienated by modern adult life. When his favorite retired college professor invites him back to his alma mater in Ohio for his retirement dinner, Jesse jumps at the chance to escape. On campus, he meets Zibby, a brilliant, precocious nineteen-year-old sophomore student who shares his deep passion for classical literature and vinyl records. An intense, intellectual romance sparks between them across campus lawns and letters, forcing Jesse to confront the boundaries of age, maturity, and living in the present rather than romanticizing the past.