The Quarry follows Valentin, a mute, reclusive drifter who arrives at a remote, dusty limestone quarry in rural South Africa to work as a manual laborer and live quietly among the local church parishioners. When the local reverend is murdered, Valentin seizes the dead man's clothes and identity, taking over the pulpit and preaching fiery sermons to the unsuspecting congregation. However, a sharp local police chief begins investigating the mysterious newcomer, suspecting that the pious new preacher is hiding a dark, violent past.