Rob Gordon is a thirty-something record store owner in Chicago who spends his time making top-five lists and obsessing over music. When his girlfriend, Laura, leaves him, he decides to revisit his five most memorable breakups to find out what is wrong with him. As he tracks down his old flames, he starts to wonder whether the problem has been his own immaturity all along. Mixing humor, music and heartbreak, the film is a sharp portrait of a man who has trouble growing up.