Ham on Rye follows a large group of suburban teenagers dressed in their finest formal wear as they gather for a mysterious, highly anticipated rite of passage at a local delicatessen. As the afternoon unfolds into evening, awkward social rituals, tentative flirtations, and teenage angst give way to a surreal, existential shift. When some teenagers are suddenly chosen to vanish into the night while others are left behind, the town's youth experience a profound awakening regarding conformity, growing up, and social exclusion.