First Cow follows a taciturn loner and skilled cook who travels west and joins a group of rough trappers in the Pacific Northwest. He soon forms a deep, meaningful friendship with a Chinese immigrant who is also seeking his fortune in the wilderness. Together, the entrepreneurial duo concoct a lucrative scheme involving the clandestine milking of the very first wealthy landowner's prized dairy cow in the territory. As their delicious baked goods become a sensation among the local frontiersmen, the constant threat of discovery hangs heavy over their budding enterprise.