Jon Martello is a handsome, muscular New Jersey bartender who cares about only a few things: his physique, his apartment, his family, his friends, his church, and internet pornography. Despite having no shortage of attractive women willing to date him, he views real-world romantic encounters as vastly inferior to his online habits. His worldview shifts when he meets Barbara, a romantic-comedy-obsessed young woman who demands a traditional fairy-tale relationship. To win her over, Jon attempts to bridge the gap between his unrealistic digital expectations and actual human intimacy.