Set in New York City during the 1990s and early 2000s, a successful political consultant in the midst of a messy divorce is asked by his inquisitive ten-year-old daughter to tell her the romantic story of how he met her mother. To keep her guessing, he changes the names of the three women he dated during that era—his college sweetheart, his ambitious career confidante, and his free-spirited bohemian artist friend—turning his romantic past into an engaging mystery puzzle. As the daughter pieces together the clues across the years, the father reflects on his political ambitions and missed timings. His heartfelt storytelling ultimately leads to a tender reconciliation.