In Los Angeles, Madeline Ashton is a vain, aging Broadway actress whose life is consumed by her obsessive rivalry with her mousy writer friend Helen Sharp, whom Madeline ruthlessly cuckolds by marrying her plastic surgeon fiancé Ernest Menville. Years later, an embittered and desperate Helen returns looking impossibly youthful and radiant, revealing the secret to her ageless beauty: a mysterious magical potion purchased from a glamorous sorceress named Lisle von Rhuman. Tempted by vanity and jealousy, Madeline visits the sorceress and drinks the potion, gaining eternal youth and immortality. However, both women soon discover the gruesome dark catch: while their bodies cannot age, they remain vulnerable to physical trauma, leading to a hilarious, backstabbing war of slapstick mutilation involving broken necks, shotgun blasts, and spray-painted skin.