Dan Burns is a widowed advice columnist who is raising three daughters on his own and struggles to take his own advice. During a family weekend on the Rhode Island coast, he meets Marie, a charming woman in a bookstore, and feels a spark for the first time in years. His joy turns to dismay when he finds out that she is the new girlfriend of his brother Mitch. Forced to spend the weekend with her under the same roof, Dan must hide his feelings while the whole family looks on.