Set in New York City, the film weaves together two contrasting, parallel moral stories. The primary narrative follows Judah Rosenthal, a successful, respected ophthalmologist and philanthropist whose long-term mistress Dolores threatens to expose their extramarital affair and financial fraud to his wife unless he leaves her, leading a desperate Judah to hire his criminal brother to have her murdered. The secondary, lighter narrative follows Cliff Stern, an idealistic, failing documentary filmmaker struggling in an unhappy marriage who falls in love with a producer while making a documentary about a pompous television celebrity. Through both stories, the film explores how the universe responds to moral transgression.