In 1609, the brilliant but troubled painter Caravaggio is in hiding after killing a man in Rome. The Pope, wanting to decide whether to pardon him, sends a mysterious investigator known as the Shadow to find out who Caravaggio really is. As the Shadow follows his trail across Italy, he speaks to the people who knew him: patrons, lovers, models and enemies. What emerges is a portrait of an artist who was both a genius and a rebel.