Beth Harper is a successful, ambitious New York art curator who is unlucky in love and cynical about romance. Traveling to Rome for her sister impulsive wedding, she visits a famous ancient fountain of love and impulsively plucks a few mysterious coins from its waters. To her astonishment, this act triggers a magical curse that causes the eccentric men who tossed the coins—including a sausage tycoon, a street magician, and a handsome reporter—to pursue her with relentless obsession. As she tries to break the magical spell, she falls genuinely in love with a charming reporter named Nick.