Brian Kilkenny and Jake Schram are lifelong best friends who grew up together in New York City and now serve as a charismatic young Catholic priest and a progressive young rabbi, respectively. Their tight-knit, harmonious lives are suddenly upended by the return of Anna Hall, their free-spirited, beautiful childhood best friend who has blossomed into a successful corporate executive. As both Brian and Jake fall deeply in love with Anna, they face an impossible crisis of faith, professional duty, and friendship. Navigating religious boundaries and romantic feelings, the trio must discover where their true loyalties lie.