Paul Biegler is a humble, jazz-loving small-town Michigan lawyer and former district attorney who takes on a controversial murder defense. He represents Army Lieutenant Frederick Manion, who admits to shooting a local bartender after his wife Laura was brutally raped. As Biegler prepares for trial, he must use all his legal cunning against a sharp state prosecutor to prove temporary insanity. The courtroom battle unfolds as a tense examination of evidence, marriage, and human morality.