An Imperfect Murder follows Angela, a successful, sophisticated New York City ballet-company manager who begins a torrid, secret affair with a charismatic, volatile younger man. When a violent altercation leaves her lover dead on her apartment floor following a heated argument, Angela panics and attempts to cover up the crime rather than call the police. As suspicious detectives close in and psychological paranoia sets in, Angela finds her glittering life unraveling into a nightmare.