Following the romantic events of the first film, Mollie and James are now happily married and raising their toddler Mikey together in a cozy apartment. Their domestic bliss is upended with the sudden arrival of Mikey's new baby sister, Julie, whose inner voice brings a whole new set of sibling rivalries, philosophical observations, and diaper disasters. As if adjusting to two children were not enough, Mollie's deadbeat brother Stuart moves in uninvited, and James struggles to balance his career as a pilot. Through it all, the babies continue sharing cynical adult insights about the chaotic adult world surrounding them.