Set in the rugged American West of the late 19th century, Dan Evans is a struggling, debt-ridden rancher and Civil War veteran striving to keep his family's land afloat during a severe drought. When notorious outlaw Ben Wade is finally captured, Evans volunteers to join a dangerous posse tasked with escorting Wade across hostile territory to catch the 3:10 afternoon train bound for Yuma prison. As the cross-country journey progresses under constant threat from Wade's loyal gang and treacherous terrain, a tense psychological game of mutual respect and survival develops between the honest rancher and the charismatic criminal.