Following the closing arguments in a murder trial, a twelve-man jury is sent to deliberate on the fate of an impoverished Puerto Rican teenager accused of murdering his abusive father. An initial vote reveals an eleven-to-one consensus for a guilty verdict, which carries an automatic death penalty. However, juror number eight holds out, arguing that reasonable doubt demands a more thorough discussion. As tensions rise inside the sweltering jury room, personal prejudices, stubborn egos, and hidden biases are systematically dismantled through passionate debate.