Monty Kessler is an intense, arrogant, grade-obsessed senior at Harvard University who is desperately writing his senior thesis to secure an honors degree and a prestigious fellowship. While carrying a stack of his thesis pages through a campus basement, Monty accidentally trips and drops his only physical copy down a coal chute, where it lands in the furnace of a homeless man living in the basement. The homeless man, Simon Wilder, refuses to return the pages unless Monty pays an extortionate daily ransom of food, clothing, and shelter. As Monty reluctantly interacts with Simon and his eccentric bohemian roommates, the cynical street philosopher teaches the privileged student invaluable life lessons about humanity beyond books.