The Comeback Trail follows Max Barber and Walter Creerson, two desperate, small-time Hollywood movie producers in 1974 who owe a massive debt to a ruthless mob boss after their latest B-movie bombs financially. To solve their financial woes and cash in on a hefty insurance payout, Max and Walter hatch a hair-brained scheme: they cast an aging, suicidal western movie icon named Duke Montana in a dangerous action stunt film, hoping he will accidentally die on set. However, to their utter dismay, the reckless actor proves indestructible, accidentally performing death-defying stunts and revitalizing his career.