On a snowy December evening in New York, Jonathan and Sara reach for the last pair of black gloves in a department store at the same moment. They spend an enchanted night together, but Sara insists on leaving their meeting to fate. She writes her phone number in a book and Jonathan writes his on a five-dollar bill, and they agree to let the universe decide if they should meet again. Years later, on the eve of their weddings to other people, both begin searching for each other.