During a dinner conversation, a group of New York writers debates whether human existence is fundamentally tragic or comic. To illustrate their opposing views, two writers imagine different versions of a story involving a woman named Melinda. In one version, Melinda arrives unexpectedly at the home of old friends, carrying emotional problems and a complicated personal history. In the other, she becomes involved with a married couple whose relationship is already unstable. Radha Mitchell portrays the same central character in both narratives, while the surrounding circumstances lead to very different outcomes. Through humor, romance, disappointment, and personal confusion, the film examines how perspective can transform the meaning of the same events.