Will Hayes is a thirty-something Manhattan political consultant in the middle of a messy divorce who is stunned when his inquisitive ten-year-old daughter Maya demands to hear the complete romantic history of how he met her mother. Reluctantly agreeing to tell the story, Will recounts his past romance trials in 1990s New York, changing the names of his three distinct ex-girlfriends to create a guessing game for Maya: the college sweetheart, the ambitious aspiring journalist, and the free-spirited bohemian artist. As Maya pieces together the clues across a decade of heartbreak and missed timing, Will realizes that his true soulmate might have been right in front of him all along. This charming romantic comedy-drama celebrates love and destiny.