Kyle Kingsbury is a handsome, rich and arrogant high school student who looks down on everyone around him. When he humiliates a classmate named Kendra, she turns out to be a witch and puts a curse on him that makes him ugly. To break the spell, he has one year to find someone who will love him despite his appearance. Isolated in a New York townhouse with only his tutor and a housekeeper for company, he begins to change.